Pine Island FL Homes & Real Estate

Although Pine Island is only 30 minutes from Ft. Myers, Florida, its secluded, waterfront charm makes it one of the West Coast’s hidden gems. The friendly residents and rural setting provide a “small town” atmosphere reminiscent of old-style Florida. The Island is home to four communities – Bokeelia, St. James City, Matlacha and Pineland – all with their own fire department, marinas, shops, and distinctive appeal.

Fringed with mangroves and three aquatic preserves, Pine Island boasts a variety of wildlife including bald eagles, manatees, osprey and heron. Flowering plants and lush greenery add to the tropical feel.

With easy access to the Gulf of Mexico, Pine Island is well known to fishing and boating enthusiasts. Affordable waterfront homes with deep boat dockage enable anyone to take advantage of the Island lifestyle. Despite the waterfront setting, Pine Island has largely escaped the concrete and skyscrapers dominant in other more touristy areas of the Coast. Zoning restrictions protect the Island from high-rise developments, assuring the Island’s allure for generations to come.

Pine Island February 23, 2024
440
Listed
157
Avg. DOM
$430.40
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$272,000
Med. List Price
440 Properties
Page 1 of 37
$49,903
Neighborhood: Pine Island Tropical Homesites
0.31
Acres
2
Days on Site
224017409
MLS
$35,907
Neighborhood: Castile Acres Unrecorded Subdivision
0.26
Acres
2
Days on Site
224017408
MLS
Open 2/23
3774 Papaya St St. James City,  FL 33956
$639,000
Neighborhood: Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3
Beds
3
Baths
1,858
Sq.Ft.
2019
Year Built
2
Days on Site
224017490
MLS
$45,000
Neighborhood: Pine Island Tropical Homesites
0.31
Acres
2
Days on Site
224017713
MLS
$750,000
Neighborhood: Knights Bokeelia Isle
2
Beds
2
Baths
1,149
Sq.Ft.
1986
Year Built
3
Days on Site
224016767
MLS
$199,900
Neighborhood: September Estates Amended
3
Beds
2
Baths
960
Sq.Ft.
1986
Year Built
3
Days on Site
224017464
MLS
$425,000
Neighborhood: St James City
2
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
1,344
Sq.Ft.
1987
Year Built
3
Days on Site
224017467
MLS
$65,000
Neighborhood: St James City
0.21
Acres
3
Days on Site
224017527
MLS
$985,000
Neighborhood: Seagull Bay
3
Beds
3
Baths
1,765
Sq.Ft.
2000
Year Built
3
Days on Site
224017535
MLS
$215,000
Neighborhood: Trailerhaven
0.07
Acres
3
Days on Site
224016699
MLS
$85,000
Neighborhood: Pine Island Tropical Homesites
0.62
Acres
4
Days on Site
224016640
MLS
$75,000
Neighborhood: Metes And Bounds
0.54
Acres
4
Days on Site
224017036
MLS