Pine Island FL Homes & Real Estate

Although Pine Island is only 30 minutes from Ft. Myers, Florida, its secluded, waterfront charm makes it one of the West Coast’s hidden gems. The friendly residents and rural setting provide a “small town” atmosphere reminiscent of old-style Florida. The Island is home to four communities – Bokeelia, St. James City, Matlacha and Pineland – all with their own fire department, marinas, shops, and distinctive appeal.

Fringed with mangroves and three aquatic preserves, Pine Island boasts a variety of wildlife including bald eagles, manatees, osprey and heron. Flowering plants and lush greenery add to the tropical feel.

With easy access to the Gulf of Mexico, Pine Island is well known to fishing and boating enthusiasts. Affordable waterfront homes with deep boat dockage enable anyone to take advantage of the Island lifestyle. Despite the waterfront setting, Pine Island has largely escaped the concrete and skyscrapers dominant in other more touristy areas of the Coast. Zoning restrictions protect the Island from high-rise developments, assuring the Island’s allure for generations to come.

Pine Island March 21, 2023
259
Listed
132
Avg. DOM
$419.96
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$230,000
Med. List Price
259 Properties
Page 1 of 22
$60,000
Neighborhood: Pine Island Cove
0.09
Acres
1
Day on Site
223021471
MLS
Large lot in Pine Island Cove 55+ Community with GULF ACCES via boat ramp. This lot does not have impact fee and come with hook up to electric, water and sewer. Community has a heated pool, spa, boat...
$250,000
Neighborhood: Kreamers Avocado Subd
5
Acres
1
Day on Site
223004086
MLS
Your chance to own a piece of paradise, away from the hustle and bustle. Build your dream home on these 5 acres in Bokeelia. There's room for everything! Convenient to boat ramps, great fishing, and...
Open 3/26
16691 Bocilla Palms #23 Bokeelia,  FL 33922
$469,000
Neighborhood: Bocilla Island Club Condo
2
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
1,130
Sq.Ft.
1984
Year Built
1
Day on Site
223021425
MLS
Welcome to paradise where the boating and fishing is world renowned! This spacious, corner condo has been been completely remodeled and well cared for. New roof 2023, AC 2021, hurricane windows 2004,...
$250,000
Neighborhood: Caugheys Ranchettes Unrecorded Subdivision
2.5
Acres
2
Days on Site
223021531
MLS
Two and a half acres in a nice private area of Pine Island. Plenty of room for a new home, and whatever else you could need. Close to great restaurants and boating.
$16,900
Neighborhood: Port Charlotte
0.23
Acres
2
Days on Site
223021634
MLS
CITY WATER AVAILABLE!! No HOAs, deed restrictions or CDDs! Conveniently located to shopping, dining, banking and all that sunny Port Charlotte has to offer. 9.3 MILES TO THE ENGLEWOOD BEACH!! New...
$925,000
Neighborhood: Gulfhaven
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,802
Sq.Ft.
2021
Year Built
2
Days on Site
223021750
MLS
Impeccable New construction home located in one of the most desirable parts of St. James city, where the Sailboat Access & large Heated Saltwater Pool are just a few of the highlights that make this...
$230,000
Neighborhood: Pine Island Cove
2
Beds
2
Baths
968
Sq.Ft.
1987
Year Built
2
Days on Site
223019530
MLS
GULF ACCESS (over boat lift or boat ramp)with awesome 2/2 furnished home located in Pine Island Cove 55+ community. This home has many upgrades new air condition & duct in 2023, new blown insulation...
$489,000
Neighborhood: Kreamers Avocado Subd
2
Beds
1
Baths
1,008
Sq.Ft.
2003
Year Built
2
Days on Site
223021366
MLS
This is an unique opportunity. One of a kind found on Pine Island. This property feathers TWO homes on a beautifully landscaped ONE ACRE PARCEL. Great annual rentals, seasonal rentals or live in one...
$340,000
Neighborhood: CHERRY ESTATES
2
Beds
2
Baths
1,032
Sq.Ft.
1988
Year Built
3
Days on Site
223021612
MLS
Move-in ready. Direct access home in the heart of Saint James City! This home has been meticulously maintained and tastefully decorated. The interior of the home renovations includes resurfaced...
$250,000
Neighborhood: Flamingo Bay
2
Beds
1
Baths
756
Sq.Ft.
1961
Year Built
3
Days on Site
223021623
MLS
Island cottage on a double lot in the Flamingo Bay Community. Handicap accessible, with open floor plan. No Hurricane Ian damage! Two mature Carambola Trees, Star Fruit , and two orange trees on the...
Open 3/22
3400 Coquina Ln St. James City,  FL 33956
$529,900
Neighborhood: Castile Acres Unrecorded Subdivision
2
Beds
2
Baths
1,305
Sq.Ft.
2019
Year Built
4
Days on Site
223020625
MLS
PEACE AND SERENITY!! The feeling you get when you walk through the double front doors to this beautiful home!! Built in 2019, with a split bedroom, open concept floor plan and very tastefully...
$279,000
Neighborhood: Manatee Bay Unrecorded Subdivision
0.24
Acres
4
Days on Site
223021393
MLS
One of the last and best waterfront lots in Manatee Bay. Cleared and filled. Dock and seawall in place.